{ "version": 1, "updated": "2026-05-24T00:00:00Z", "agents": { "writer": { "lifetime_score": 110, "tier": 1, "events_given": 7, "events_received": 25, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 149 }, "architect": { "lifetime_score": 237, "tier": 2, "events_given": 12, "events_received": 20, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 281 }, "hunter": { "lifetime_score": 55, "tier": 1, "events_given": 4, "events_received": 11, "last_run": "008", "total_score": 74 }, "quarterback": { "lifetime_score": 220, "tier": 2, "events_given": 13, "events_received": 16, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 262 }, "listener": { "lifetime_score": 155, "tier": 2, "events_given": 11, "events_received": 11, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 188 }, "draper": { "lifetime_score": 97, "tier": 1, "events_given": 8, "events_received": 13, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 126 }, "market-analyst": { "lifetime_score": 100, "tier": 2, "events_given": 8, "events_received": 10, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 126 }, "audit-quality": { "lifetime_score": 90, "tier": 1, "events_given": 7, "events_received": 11, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 115 }, "storyteller": { "lifetime_score": 285, "tier": 2, "events_given": 14, "events_received": 9, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 322 }, "debrief": { "lifetime_score": 145, "tier": 2, "events_given": 11, "events_received": 10, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 177 }, "tech-translator": { "lifetime_score": 97, "tier": 1, "events_given": 9, "events_received": 13, "last_run": "019", "total_score": 128 } }, "events": [ { "run_id": "001", "from": "storyteller", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 20, "score": 60, "description": "Identified 'system before system existed' narrative, reframing TASK-001 scope", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "listener", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Named the three severed nerves (notify, execute, dispatch)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "architect", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Provided SwarmEvent schema for TASK-002", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "draper", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Identified confirm/feedback/recovery UX pattern", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 1, "score": 3, "description": "Calculated Supabase free tier headroom (35 months at 14MB/mo)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Listed all jargon leaking into UI labels", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "quarterback", "to": "debrief", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Produced dependency graph and wave sequencing", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "debrief", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Extracted auth identity pattern (login vs email vs ID)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "001", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Found ALLOWED_GITHUB_LOGIN default bug (org vs user login)", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "architect", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Single canonical ExaClient + 22-col process_runs schema (TASK-001 subset)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "listener", "to": "hunter", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "15 unfollowed Debbie-named warm contacts surfaced from in_scope[].debbie_note_raw", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "storyteller", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Spine sentence synthesizes 4 sub-agents into one story", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "quarterback", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Phase 8 ships before Stage D so dossiers auto-log", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "11-jargon-term replacement table", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "conductor", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Recovery script reconstructed 12 dossiers from process_runs after Stage D crash", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "hunter", "to": "market-analyst", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "L&D / credentialing buyer cohort identified (Pearson, LRN, Skillsoft, Vector, Relias)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "all", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "10 HR-tech comp transactions cited; mega-PE refuted at 6M CAD scale", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "draper", "to": "listener", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Amplified Debbie-row-38 HRCI signal as the headline finding", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "002", "from": "writer", "to": "tech-translator", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Pre-flagged 4 jargon terms in dossier templates", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "storyteller", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 20, "score": 60, "description": "Identified three disconnected systems as core coherence failure", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "architect", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Complete 16-table SQL migration ready for Wave 0 builder spec", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Clay pricing correction ($0.02 to $0.30-$1.00) prevented budget surprise", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "listener", "to": "draper", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "System IS the team insight enabled emotional design framing", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "hunter", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Clay table schema + people pipeline design saved architecture iteration", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "writer", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Found existing migrated tables with 0 rows prevented duplicate schema", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "quarterback", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "11-wave dependency graph with overnight MVP scope definition", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "draper", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Feedback box as free enrichment disguised as collaboration reframe", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "listener", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Chat command vocabulary design enabling filter engine architecture", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "47-term jargon audit with customer-friendly replacements", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "debrief", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "knowledge_atoms universal table design for long-term unification", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003", "from": "debrief", "to": "listener", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Learning loop inventory identifying 4 broken feedback loops to fix first", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "hunter", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Mercer confirmed active HR.com sponsor — turned generic sponsor angle into specific pitch point", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "listener", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Workday CareerXroads April 2025 acquisition — direct community precedent landed as top Workday opener", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "debrief", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Workforce Software acquired by ADP Oct 2024 — prevented cold call to a no-longer-independent entity", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "EagleTree highest-conviction buyer flag: owns Arc/LRP HR Tech conference — gave writer the strongest opener hook", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "architect", "to": "all", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "company_id exact-match join confirmed — zero mismatches in 83-company merge", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "storyteller", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Paychex $4.1B Paycor deal + Vensure 108 acquisitions = two franchise anchor stories for HCM/PEO callers", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Self-describing format ({Column Name}: {value}) standardized across all 83 companies — prevents caller confusion", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "003-diallist", "from": "quarterback", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "3-batch parallel split (A/B/C, 28/28/27 companies) completed all 83 in one pass without re-run", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "debrief", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Signal Deployment Status table — new artifact closing observation-to-deployment gap", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "storyteller", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "SKILL.md version control gap flagged — revert cycle demonstrates signal-loss risk without trace", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "quarterback", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Surfaced missed CODE evidence — check_acquisition() in next-chapter-brain, not next-chapter-os", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "quarterback", "to": "audit-quality", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "DOC/CODE/DATA dependency chain framework — structured 3-point verification checklist", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "quarterback", "to": "all", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Single root cause across all 3 gaps: every incomplete signal stopped one handoff before executing layer", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "storyteller", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Signal 1 write happened in session 004 not 003 Phase 6 — Phase 6 cache rule not self-executed", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "debrief", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Last-mile handoff diagnosis — every signal stopped one layer above execution", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "004-enrichment-audit", "from": "architect", "to": "salesfinity-loader", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Gate 7 gap identification + stranded check_acquisition() utility pointer", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "storyteller", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "Two-actor model: nc_app (runtime REST) ≠ postgres superuser (apply-time DDL) — ended 3-session migration authority confusion", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "storyteller", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Live data IS the proof: 7 deals + 16+ tables + 4 docs confirmed migration success — established 'live data = applied' rule", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "quarterback", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 10, "score": 30, "description": "PR #36 stale-status catch — verified MERGED at 22:52 UTC when briefing claimed still open", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "debrief", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 10, "score": 20, "description": "Dual-ledger disambiguation: public.schema_migrations (custom 0004 ledger) ≠ supabase_migrations.schema_migrations (CLI internal)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "debrief", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "migrate.sh ledger gap: INSERT into schema_migrations missing after each psql call — prevents silent seed re-run overwrites", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "architect", "to": "all", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "iss_0254 + iss_0255 proactively logged before first miss — swarm archive drift and hardcoded RUNS array documented", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "listener", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Surfaced 'may already be fixed' as audit scope boundary — focused panel on current state, not historical notes", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "005-migration-audit", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 1, "base": 5, "score": 5, "description": "FIX-AND-SHIP verdict with ledger-disambiguation correction applied before archiving", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "007", "from": "quarterback", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 1, "score": 3, "description": "calendar-gating each stage by risk + active-deal touchpoint", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "007", "from": "listener", "to": "all", "multiplier": 3, "base": 1, "score": 3, "description": "surfaced symlink-drift as the actual pain (not repo count)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "007", "from": "storyteller", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 1, "score": 3, "description": "bumper-sticker test forced one-sentence repo identity", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "007", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "ewing", "multiplier": 1, "base": 1, "score": 1, "description": "priced trade: $12,715/yr saved, 6-week payback", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "007", "from": "architect", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 3, "base": 1, "score": 3, "description": "pre-flight pack-size + bun grep before cutover", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "007", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 1, "score": 3, "description": "caught fabricated verdict + missing journals + missing notebook before push", "verified_by": "self" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "storyteller", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "One-sentence thesis + story-first structure rec prevents criteria-first report failure", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "storyteller", "to": "market-analyst", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Named PE saturation gap definition problem; forced saturation data with tier qualifiers", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "storyteller", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-named Phase 2 coherence gap (PE-undersaturated vs. owner-feels-urgency split) so conductor could watch for it in consolidation", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "listener", "to": "draper", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "5 RSVP-yes triggers delivered as structural frame for invitation copy", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "listener", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Referral source map flagged as parallel deliverable; warm-referral conversion delta (30-50% vs 5-10%) quantified", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "draper", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Exit-readiness framing + 4 vertical invitation hooks (copy-ready)", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "draper", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Owner psychology frame (pest control owners already know their multiple) shaped top-5 scoring", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "architect", "to": "hunter", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-defined lal_* key schema + dedup strategy before discovery runs", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "architect", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Supabase NC-LAL-EVENT campaign row gap + 4 downstream gaps flagged before outreach was planned", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "writer", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Production-ready HTML skeleton with inline CSS, sortable tables, 4-tier color scale", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "writer", "to": "tech-translator", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Dual-version problem raised in Phase 1, validates tech-translator's independent finding and elevates to pattern", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Translation glossary (8 terms, three-column) + plain-English executive summary draft for HTML hero section", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Two-document-layers architecture decision flagged as structural choice before Phase 5 — prevented writer from building wrong single document", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "10-item checklist caught Fire Protection PE rating error, missing data quality banner, Alliance Environmental flag, and journal gap — all fixed before Phase 6 close", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "swarm-upgrade", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "2 upgrade-signal:gap items + 1 upgrade-signal:currency item identified for swarm-upgrade to process", "verified_by": "conductor" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "quarterback", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Quality checklist (10 fields) + definition of done for sales rep readiness", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "quarterback", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Dependency map + recommended revenue band expansion to $5M–$75M", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "debrief", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Journal standards checklist prevents Phase-6 skip pattern from run #007", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "hunter", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "WebSearch permission block documented with recovery protocol for future runs", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "008", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "4 verticals with scored PE saturation + TSMC/Intel commercial trades tailwind flag for fire protection callers", "verified_by": "audit-quality" }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "architect", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-sequenced rollout dependencies: GitHub Actions webhook → per-machine listener → fallback LaunchAgent poll, with explicit 'Charlie/Bear laptop = poll-only because no Tailscale yet' note — saves quarterback re-deriving graph" }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "architect", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Listed every claude-skills reference in repo (CLAUDE.md L11, L19; legacy README.md auto-archive note) so writer can ship the cleanup PR without re-grepping" }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "architect", "to": "listener", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Confirmed Anthropic's hosted Skills API is per-surface (API/Claude.ai/Code don't sync) — saves listener proposing a hosted-distribution path that doesn't exist" }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "architect", "to": "market-analyst", "multiplier": 2, "base": 1, "score": 2, "description": "Flagged that 'rev-parse --short HEAD origin/main' is in Ewing's allowlist — proves a third clone exists at ~/Desktop/next-chapter-os and is actively used; prevents market-analyst from miscounting operator surfaces" }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "4 blocking FAILs caught before Phase 5 render: Ewing Desktop omission, UserPromptSubmit not-removed, branch-protection ticket missing, quarterly audit-skills not operationalized — all fixed inline, saving a SEND-BACK cycle." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Skill-receiver.sh underspecification (auth key name, last-SHA path, comparison logic) caught before implementation — prevents the agent writing the script from having to ask three follow-up questions." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "audit-quality", "to": "swarm-upgrade", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Cowork surface ambiguity (separate machine vs existing-machine surface) flagged as a PARTIAL — queued for swarm-upgrade to resolve with actual Cowork deployment topology." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "debrief", "to": "audit-quality", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-staged Signal Deployment Status table with 7 candidate rows in Phase 1, so audit-quality's Phase 4 protocol P7 check has structure to score against instead of an empty section." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "debrief", "to": "swarm-upgrade", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-tagged 7 upgrade signals (3 gap, 2 audit, 1 dissent, 1 currency) with grep-friendly inline tags so swarm-upgrade Phase 1 detection runs without scanning unstructured prose." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "draper", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Provided the trust-ledger and silent-failure inventory architect needs to choose between push channels — shifts the criterion from 'lowest latency' to 'best observable-signal-per-event,' which kills the notification-firehose anti-pattern before it ships." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "draper", "to": "tech-translator", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "First-60-seconds onboarding sketch gives tech-translator a concrete user journey to write Charlie/Bear-facing copy against — replaces abstract 'onboarding-trivial' constraint with a literal time-stamped walkthrough." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "draper", "to": "storyteller", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Dignity test (zero 'did you pull?' messages in six months) gives storyteller a single measurable narrative arc to test consensus output against — prevents the swarm from shipping an architecture that's technically right but emotionally hollow." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "listener", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Named the observable trust signal (heartbeat file + session-start status line) as the load-bearing unstated requirement — shifted architect's substrate criterion from latency-first to observable-failure-first, preventing a silent-when-broken architecture." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "listener", "to": "draper", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Surfaced B6 (operator dignity) as the emotional translation of the no-pull rule — gave draper the bridge from technical constraint to human stakes so empathy section wasn't generic." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "listener", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Documented Anthropic's team-skills community convention (Git-fetcher + manifest schema) so quarterback's rollout sequencing could cite a precedent instead of inventing from scratch." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "p99 latency analysis (GitHub Actions: 120-270s under queue spike) proved Actions alone fails the <60s target — forced the architect-vs-market-analyst apparent conflict to resolve correctly as substrate vs push-channel separation." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "$12,400/yr drift-loss baseline + +$16,478 NPV over 24 months gave conductor a cost frame that justified the $25/mo Supabase Pro spend and made the hybrid architecture ROI-positive in the same paragraph." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "market-analyst", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Confirmed Anthropic Skills API as VAPORWARE (no public retail SKU, no SLA, confidence LOW) — eliminated one substrate option before Phase 3 synthesis, reducing quarterback's rollout decision surface." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "quarterback", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Produced the 8-ticket linear dependency chain (SKILL-SYNC-00 through SKILL-SYNC-07) with canary sequencing (Ewing MacBook → Mac mini → interns) — gave conductor a concrete rollout scaffold instead of an abstract sequence." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "quarterback", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-defined 7-column ticket schema (id/owner/depends_on/ship_window/success_signal/rollback) so writer's Phase 5 table render was paste-in, not redesign." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "quarterback", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Flagged that any plan requiring Charlie/Bear to run a setup script is a non-starter — forced bootstrap.sh curl-only onboarding into the architecture spec before Phase 3 synthesis." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "storyteller", "to": "draper", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Dignity test framing (zero 'did you pull?' messages in six months) gave draper a measurable narrative arc and a falsifiable claim — prevented swarm from shipping an architecture that's technically right but emotionally hollow." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "storyteller", "to": "audit-quality", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Identified the Anthropic marketplace as a 'bets production on a roadmap item' anti-pattern — gave audit-quality a concrete rejection reason for the vaporware substrate option before Phase 4 check." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "storyteller", "to": "conductor", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Coherence-tested the Claude Desktop 'next session open' limitation as a platform limit not a design gap — prevented Phase 5 writer from hedging or apologizing for a hard constraint that cannot be fixed." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "writer", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-built glossary and constraint-translation table so writer's Phase 4 draft can use plain-language constraint wording without waiting for Phase 5 polish." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "self", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Changed own process: front-loaded translation in Phase 1 instead of waiting for Phase 5, fulfilling the S6 delta from run #017." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "tech-translator", "to": "draper", "multiplier": 2, "base": 1, "score": 2, "description": "Provided three operator-specific 'what changed for me' paragraphs draper can plug into the empathy-pass section without rewriting from scratch." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "writer", "to": "architect", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Pre-built 11-section document outline with substrate-comparison table schema slot — architect's pick fits without rework; Phase 5 writer did not have to redesign the document to accommodate the chosen substrate." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "writer", "to": "quarterback", "multiplier": 3, "base": 5, "score": 15, "description": "Defined 7-column rollout ticket schema (id/owner/depends_on/ship_window/success_signal/rollback) in Phase 1 so quarterback's sequencing output was structured and paste-ready into Phase 5 HTML table." }, { "run_id": "2026-05-07__019__skills-sync-architecture", "from": "writer", "to": "tech-translator", "multiplier": 2, "base": 5, "score": 10, "description": "Specified engineer-to-operator register + banned-phrases list up front so Phase 5 plain-language sweep was a pass, not a rewrite." } ] }