Run: 2026-05-05__009__buyside-hunt-routine-review · Date: 2026-05-05 · Phase 4 maker-checker
Phase 4 verdict: CONCERNS 80/100. Passes the 80 floor but two items at exactly 5/10 (Reusability, Production readiness) need work before Slackbot exposure. Functional correctness, output completeness, copy compliance, security, and visual readability all scored 9 or 10.
ItemScore Functional correctness9/10 Output completeness10/10 Copy quality (banned phrases)10/10 Visual readability9/10 Reusability5/10 Error handling7/10 Observability9/10 Documentation6/10 Security / secrets10/10 Production readiness5/10 Total80/100
Could not test the pipeline under concurrent load (5 simultaneous /buyside-hunt invocations). Production-readiness concerns about Exa rate limits, run-id collisions, and Doppler env are theoretical until measured.
Pattern: a pipeline can score 9/10 on every functional and copy axis and still flunk production-readiness because it lacks auth, rate limits, and async dispatch. Recommend a separate Slackbot-exposure pre-flight checklist invoked any time a CLI tool is being wrapped for external triggering.
The deliverable is presentable today. The slash-command exposure is not. Three fixes shipped same day in W7; production-readiness is the open ticket.
Generated from 009__audit-quality.md — do not edit this HTML directly.